The Appellate Tribunal for Electricity (APTEL) has ruled in favour of wind power generators in a batch of 23 appeals challenging orders passed by the Andhra Pradesh Electricity Regulatory Commission (APERC). In its judgment pronounced on November 17, 2026, the tribunal set aside APERC’s directions restricting payments for wind energy generated beyond the normative Capacity Utilisation Factor (CUF). It held that generators are entitled to receive the applicable agreed tariff for all electricity supplied to distribution companies, irrespective of whether annual generation exceeds the normative CUF.
The dispute involved Power Purchase Agreements (PPAs) signed between wind power generators and the Southern Power Distribution Company of Andhra Pradesh Limited (APSPDCL). Under APERC’s tariff orders, generic tariffs were determined based on a normative CUF. For instance, its November 15, 2012 order fixed a tariff of ₹4.70 per unit based on a normative CUF of 23% for 25 years from the Commercial Operation Date.
However, through several orders issued between September 2022 and July 2024, APERC treated normative CUF as a payment limit. It directed that electricity generated beyond this benchmark would receive only ₹0.50 per unit, along with provisions for cumulative annual CUF adjustments.
Several wind power developers challenged these directions before APTEL. One such case involved Beta Wind Farm Private Limited, which disputed the restriction of payments for electricity supplied between July 2016 and July 2017. The distribution companies, including APSPDCL, also filed cross-appeals, arguing that excess generation should either remain unpaid or be considered through fresh tariff proceedings.
The APTEL bench comprising Judicial Member Virender Bhat and Technical Member Ajay Talegaonkar examined whether APERC had the authority to introduce different payment arrangements for electricity generated beyond normative CUF.
The tribunal clarified that normative CUF is an annual benchmark used for calculating fixed costs and determining generic tariffs. Since wind generation depends on changing weather conditions, actual electricity output can vary significantly from year to year. Therefore, normative CUF cannot be treated as a separate billing limit or used to divide electricity into regular and excess generation.
APTEL also observed that the PPAs did not contain any provision restricting payments to electricity generated within the normative CUF. The agreements specified monthly limits based on contracted export capacity and operating hours rather than an annual generation cap.
The tribunal further noted that wind developers already bear the risks associated with lower wind availability and generation shortfalls. Restricting payments for additional electricity would discourage generators from supplying more power during favourable wind conditions.
Accordingly, APTEL set aside the ₹0.50 per unit payment provision and cumulative CUF adjustment directions. It directed that all delivered electricity must be paid at the applicable generic tariff under the respective PPAs. The tribunal also rejected APSPDCL’s request for remanding the matter to APERC and ordered payment of withheld amounts along with applicable interest under the agreements.
Discover more from SolarQuarter
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
RELATED ARTICLES
Subscribe Today
GET EXCLUSIVE FULL ACCESS TO PREMIUM CONTENT
SUPPORT CLEANTECH JOURNALISM
EXPERT ANALYSIS OF AND EMERGING TRENDS
TOPICAL VIDEO WEBINARS
Get unlimited access to our EXCLUSIVE Content and our archive of subscriber stories.
Exclusive content this week
Latest article










